Stonehauler
Well-Known Member
I would argue that transmissions are about being able to control your car by ensuring you are in the power band as you are wanting to put the foot down…or using the engine as a brake down long steep hills, etc. for thing like parlor tricks of making an engine crackle…that’s going to be the engine. I test drove a 2022 b,w 550i that I was a hair’s width away from pulling the trigger on…and that thing would crackle and pop just taking your foot off the accelerometer suddenly.Yeah they're faster but I'd rather have a manual to do tricks with and for the most control. To me all you can do with an automatic that's fun is speed. I rented a 911 with the PDK and in sport plus mode it was kind of fun and you could downshift and pop the factory catback exhaust but still.
I get it, people who like manuals have “reasons” they do, but in the end, it’s about controlling the car and I can do that just as well, if not better, in a modern manumatic.
if they offer a manual, great!, but manuals are not the king (my opinion only) of the transmissions like they were. It’s a recent transition and people have decades of when the manual was top of the heap, but the last 5-15 years (depending on the car) have changed things up. DCT is the new king, and automatic has nudged the manual aside. however, if that’s what you want, I hope it is offered, because options are always nice to have So long as that’s option doesn’t preclude them offering better options, like better performing more powerful/more reliable motors.
Sponsored